The National Geographic has sent John Walkenbach, author of my favorite weblog J-Walk Blog, a Copyright Complaint letter.
I am disappointed because John's posts did not, in my opinion, take away from the National Geographic. He did not reproduce entire articles or even a substantial portion of articles. He merely posted interesting snippets with links to National Geographic for the entire articles. In my view, he merely provided free advertising.
I would have much more sympathy for the National Geographic position if John had claimed authorship, reproduced substantial portions of the articles, or was deprived National Geographic of revenue and profits. I do not believe National Geographic suffered any harm. Rather, I believe National Geographic only benefitted from John Walkenbach's exposure.
Although I have never met John, I have tremendous respect for him. While I do not agree with all, or even many of, his views, I do appreciate his willingness to voice his opinions. And I do appreciate his effort that he puts into his blog to entertain his readers. I am absolutely positive that John meant no harm and, indeed, caused no harm to National Geographic.
As a fan and fellow blogger, I want to add my voice to denounce National Geographic's position.
Leave a comment