Oil Speculators Are To Blame
The article Oil Summit to Take on Speculators (subscription required) in today's Wall Street Journal mentions that high powered officials are looking at the role of speculators.
Officials from around the world, including U.K. Prime Minister Gordon Brown and U.S. Energy Secretary Samuel Bodman, along with the chief executives of major oil companies, will meet Sunday to discuss oil prices, investment, and the role of speculators.
"From a global perspective, we definitely think it's time that financial markets and their regulators take a tough look at how transparent is this market and what needs to be done to improve it," a contributor to the working paper said Saturday, "and if there is a need for regulation, how that regulation should tackle the issues."
Seeking diversification and a hedge against inflation, institutional investors such as pension funds and endowments have invested some of their billions into financial contracts passively following indexes composed of a basket of commodity futures.
...
Governments must help stabilize the oil market, by taking action against speculators, Saudi Arabia's deputy oil minister Prince Abdel Aziz bin Salman was reported as saying, according to remarks re-published from Asharq Al-Awsat newspaper by the state-run Kuwaiti news agency Saturday.
The reality is that speculators are not to blame. Typically, when speculators push the price of a good beyond a reasonable level, producers begin producing to capture excess profits. However, in this instance, producers are not producing. Moreover, producers are not showing their cards as to what they can or cannot produce. That is, Saudi Arabia does not allow independent assessments of its oil fields. Thus, investors and speculators can only guess.
If OPEC had the ability to open the spigots, I believe it would. It would do so to unsettle the backers and supporters of large scale mega projects, such as Alberta oil sands mega projects. If prices were to plummet dramatically for a year or two, investors would think long and hard before spending billions to develop these massive and capital intensive energy projects.
The oil summit on 22 June 2008 could prove counterproductive. After the jawboning by Saudi Arabia earlier to increase its production by a measly two hundred thousand barrels per day, and after many Asian countries have reduced their fuel subsidies, fuel prices remain stubbornly high. Should the summit produce some important pronouncements with no noticeable effects, then it will be that much more difficult to convince speculators and others that oil remains in plentiful supply and that speculators are to blame for the current mess.
Blaming speculators is easy. Fixing the root cause of high oil prices is not.
